“The New Millennium…………..SUCKS!”
Lewis Black—
Or at the very least, the first decade of it turned out to be less than average—and I’m not even talking about all the current events that surrounded them; This is more about the aftermath behind those events, especially in the world of Pop Music. Gone were all the bright colors and rhythmic beats, in came a lot of guitars and anger (and the less said about NuMetal, the better). As always, SNL was there as people’s moods shifted at whiplash speeds—thing is, sometimes the speeds go so fast that it’s hard to keep up with what’s hip and current during this time. Think about it; the Decade started with remnants of 90s pop for about 21 months—Then the world lost its mind in a way that caused practically every musician in the world to do things in a solemn/low key way for a little while…And Then, when the country realized it needed to fight back, the music started to become a little more defiant—if not heavy handed…And THEN, after re-electing America’s Cowboy in ’04, the music became less about defiance and more about Anger…AND THEN, the shift goes from Anger to just plain emo burnout/fatigued after being angry for so long…AND THEN once we upgraded our leadership, certain genres tried to regain the spotlight while crossing over into other genres at the same time—which is where the trend pretty much stayed up until the turn of the decade where it all went to hell in a handbasket (though more on That decade come January 2020). Despite the country and the population’s musical tastes having more mood swings than somebody with Post-Partum, SNL was still there to try and keep up with the times—even if some of the people watching eventually started to ignore music altogether and instead focus on the comedy (or, depending on the season, focusing our venom towards whatever anti-comedy wound up happening that week). Anyway, enough preamble, let’s get to some music…
REMINDERS:
*These performances have to come from Actual, Credited Musical Guests (Though for this list, I’m gonna have to make a MAJOR exception).
*Only the performances from the calendar decade (2000 to 2009) will count.
*Performances will be judged based on:
(1) Song popularity; both in the public’s perception and in my own musical tastes.
(2) How iconic the performer is.
(3) How memorable the performance was on the show
HOWEVER, we’re going to make an adjustment in scoring; instead of everything being judged evenly this time; you have to realize that at the turn of the century, People REALLY upped their game when it came to Production Value. So for our remaining 2 lists, the scoring is now going to be 30/30/40 respectively.
*I should also probably point out that at this point in my life, I had begun working in radio—particularly, at a station that began as Country, but then flipped to classic hits. I say this because first and foremost, I am NOT—repeat, NOT—well versed in the world of “Pop” music, so my apologies in advance if I leave certain performers out either by accident or on purpose.
*SNL Performances where applicable, otherwise I’ll put up the studio recording/music video of it.
…and before you ask, NO, I am NOT gonna bring up Sean Paul/Adrien Brody on this list. First, I already mentioned the incident on one of our “Misplaced Mojo” pieces; and second, even without the incident ever happening, I really hate that song…I’ve got my reasons.
- KANYE WEST – HEARTLESS/PINOCCHIO STORY (12/13/2008) – Whether you find him to be a fascinating case study (for something neurological, no doubt), or somebody who’s just downright infuriating, You can’t deny that every time he’s appeared on the show—not just here, but into the next decade—He’s always going to do something that’s going to get people to tune in; whether it be something abstract, jaw dropping or just plain stupid. In the case of this decade, Yeezy got my attention by invoking the image of Elroy Jetson…because who does that? In 2008? On Late Night TV? But that’s 2nd to the fact that up until this point in show history, MG performances were not exactly known for being High Tech—with RARE exceptions. In fact, I would’ve ranked this higher were it not for the fact that the songs themselves weren’t any of West’s Bests. Truth be told, his performance of “Champion” a year earlier was the better-performed song; and of course, we all know “Gold Digger” in 2005 is untouchable no matter what. But visual mesmerization does weigh a little heavy here—something that West would do in his subsequent appearances, for Better or Worse.
- FOO FIGHTERS: TIMES LIKE THESE (2/22/2003) – It breaks my heart that I can’t find the actual show performance where Jim Carrey surprises us by playing alongside the band with his leg…but that would’ve been too easy. Truth be told, that’s why the song is on the list to begin with; wild cards like that are always a nice bonus. Nevertheless, I can still have this song on the list for just how on-point Mr. Grohl & Co. are by this point in their history. No longer are they “The Drummer from Nirvana and some other guys”; instead, they become a modern alt rock staple (as well as the lifelong fan of a certain late night talk show host…more on that in January) who every time they come on rip the roof off the place. Not only that, but Grohl especially becomes more and more powerful with every successive performance; no longer keen to simply “beating drums as though it owed him money” (to quote a random Youtube user), Grohl became a force to be reckoned with slowly but surely.
- PRINCE: FURY (2/3/2006) – When the Purple one famously flaked out on the show in 1995, one would think that his royal badness would’ve permanently made the show’s shit list for leaving them twisting in the wind (supposedly…jury’s still out on exactly WHY he bailed out in the first place, it could’ve been legit for all we know). But if we’ve learned anything from the likes of Elvis Costello, Ben Stiller and other people who have been away from the show for a lengthy period of time due to stupid decisions, it’s that nobody should hold a grudge forever; and that is why we thank the merciful music gods that when Prince came back to 8H the same night Steve Martin came back after his own lengthy absence, the stars aligned so that he could give us one hell of a performance–almost literally on the “Hell” part due to how much fiery imagery was involved. As a matter of fact, one could argue that so much effort was put in to this performance that one would wonder if Prince was simply making up for lost time from 11 years earlier when he was still “The Artist” and most people turned on him because of it. “Fury” was proof that Prince didn’t give a fuck what other people thought, and he decided to rock on anyway. It also may have been because of performing on a Live TV venue that he was able to perform one year later at the biggest Live TV venue of them all; and he was able to prove once and for all that he would be a flake no more.
- BECK: CLAP HANDS (10/28/2006) – Coincidentally coming from Another episode that Hugh Laurie happened to have hosted; Whereas Kanye upped the game when it came to being High tech, it may have actually been Mr. Hansen that was the prototype for Special/Practical effects—Going so far as to perform one of his lesser known songs from the Guerro album alongside a simultaneous set of Marrionettes. When I first saw this on TV, my immediate reaction ranged from “The Hell?” to “OK, that’s kinda cool” within the span of 3 minutes; and for good reason too—I gotta give this one the extra point for attention to detail; which, for Live TV is pretty damn hard to do, even if I were to watch it over and over in reruns just to see what I missed. Everything from a mock up of the set design, to what Beck & his bandmates were wearing, even the props that were being delivered to them were being duplicated at (presumably) 1/15th the scale…most importantly, it was a deviation from the default—anybody can simply “Perform” on the show, but it takes a special kind to turn a performance into performance art.
- EMINEM ft. DIDO: STAN (10/7/2000) – Before this song wound up changing the game for Marshall Mathers; a lot of people were ready to write him off as simply being “The Slim Shady Guy”, even though he had already proven himself as a durable performer (though assists from Dre & Snoop Dogg kinda helped a bit). This piece not only went on to prove the naysayers wrong in a big way, but it also altered Em’s chemistry (or should that be “chEMƎstry”?) for the better. It was because of this piece that critics and fans alike began to take him seriously—even if he was still very much a lightning rod of controversy at that point…what, with the homophobic lyrics and whatnot. Still though, this piece showed us a side of Em that we either didn’t know existed, wanted to exist, or even he wanted to expose to us. But it’s a good thing that he did, because were it not for how vulnerable the performance was, Em could never achieve levels of well-roundedness that most performers often lack—dare I say, were it not for “Stan”, Em wouldn’t make the leap toward “8 Mile”; “Lose Yourself” would Never win an Oscar, and Em would probably revert back to Marshall Mathers: Private Citizen. Of course, it also helped a great deal that English Singer/Lilith Fair Staple/”Roswell” theme song performer Dido gave him the A-OK to sample her existing hit “Thank You” in order to pull off one of the most unlikely crossovers of the decade (as well as turning the name “Stan” into an abject term for being an obsessive fan)
- JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE: CRY ME A RIVER (10/11/2003) – I want to save a little time in November to talk about this, and other things that made the maligned 29 less sucky; but as a prologue, I hope you don’t mind my burying the lead a little. It’s easy to see Timberlake NOW as one of the staples of SNL not just in this decade, but the 21st century in general—but all the way back in 2003, in spite of how much he commanded a young female audience; the general consensus was that thanks to his years in N*SYNC, he was probably (through NO fault of his own, BTW) one of the nation’s most punchable people Just because he was a part of the group. And when it was announced that he, and he alone would be hosting/MG the 2nd show of Season 29, a lot of us (Myself included) were just about ready to expect/brace for the worst. Then again, simply saying “Boy Bands Suck” back then at a young age was less a declaration and more of a protector towards those who wanted to kick your ass that week…I’m not a betting man, but if I had Millions of Dollars and wagered that this episode would be one of the worst of all time, you’d be talking to somebody living in poverty right now and typing this list from a public library—because not only did Timberlake let our defenses down, but he all but destroyed any chance that he could be a punchable figure with his performance on this show—and I’m not even talking about the sketches, he showed the world that he didn’t need 4 other guys holding him back. In particular on this song; which, out of the 3 he did that night, would later go on to become one of his signature pieces. I know judging a book by its cover is about as cliché as you can get, but JT dispelled the cliché once and for all that night.
- U2: ELEVATION (12/9/2000) – This is gonna be one of those times where the Studio or even Live Concert versions of the songs will make it IMPOSSIBLE to give the SNL version any justice; but take it from somebody who saw this performance on Live TV as they were happening, this one threw out the rulebook. Once upon a Time in the year 2000 (sorry, had to), U2 was enjoying probably it most significant comeback in its career so far—Thanks in part to the laughable “Pop” album, Bono & the Boys had to prove to everybody that what happened there was a joke. Nobody was laughing when “All that you can’t leave behind” was released; not only did this feel like a return of sorts to the “Vintage” sound that the band was famous for back in the 80s & non-sell out Early 90s, but it was adjusted enough so that things would continue to sound fresh in the next century…Which brings us to when they appeared for the first time in 2000. Of course, they performed what was the biggest song of the album by that point; “Beautiful Day”. When it came time for Bono & Co. to do “Elevation”, one thought failed to occur to the average SNL fan that Bono chose to raise that night—just exactly how much of the Studio Space in 8H can one be willing to use for a performance? Turns out; just enough to turn an otherwise strong song into a total experience not just for the studio audience, but for the people watching at home. From messing around with the cameras, to straight up mingling with the audience, Bono pretty much had the room in the palm of his hand by that point…so much so, that 4 years later, Bono tried to capture lightning in a bottle a 2nd time by pretty much doing the same thing (only with more lap dancing to audience members) for a show closing performance of “I Will Follow” (ALSO UNAVAILABLE). Thankfully, Bono & Co. would tone themselves down a little by the time of their 2009 & 2017 performances; but were it not for them, future MG performances wouldn’t have the right to become more freewheeling as time marched on.
- PAUL SIMON: THE BOXER (9/29/2001) – Yes, I know, it’s a cheat. And yes, I know, I’m closing out the list with the same guy for a 3rd time. But As cliché as it may sound, I legitimately had to debate myself over whether or not to include this performance. After all, it broke the rule that Simon wasn’t a credited performer that night; but on the other hand, who The Hell else could possibly fit into this position—and for quite the most noble of reasons? 18 days after the 9/11 attacks occurred, there was the lingering thought of “Returning to Normal” after it happened; For all intents and purposes, all the talk shows came back and addressed it, various scripted shows hastily put together shows that addressed it (though South Park remains the king there thanks to its short Turnaround time), but for SNL to address the attacks would be the true test to see just how “Normal” things would go back to being. We of course begin with Mayor Giuliani (still on his meds and walking free back then) encouraging us to visit New York, as well as introducing the Firefighters and Policemen that worked around the clock to help. After that, we take a sudden swing over to the MG stage, and along comes one of the greatest residents of the borough of Queens performing a song that was less about New York City, but more about overcoming day to day struggles in a seemingly unforgiving environment—and NYC just happened to be that environment. The detailed history of the song itself is a story for another click, but as far as this performance goes, it did exactly what it was supposed to do: It honored a city that just recently experienced the worst of humanity while getting hit from all ends; and while the song itself is somewhat dour by nature, it’s still very much a rallying call of defiance towards those that have ever felt like they were the underdog. The fact that a City that’s always been known for having it all suddenly found itself thrust into that position will probably be the most jarring reminder that nobody in this world is immortal—but it is because of “The Boxer” that no matter how mortal the City can be at times, it can still be resilient. Sidebar: Not even the uncomfortable close-up of Giuliani near the end could ruin the magnitude of the performance; it is THAT profound of a piece. Then, of course, you get the classic ending where Lorne ask the Mayor “Can we be Funny?” To which Rudy replies “Why Start Now?” Marking the last time the Mayor made us laugh intentionally…But I digress.
SPECIAL (DIS) HONORABLE MENTION:
ASHLEE SIMPSON & HER “ACID REFLUX” (10/23/2004) – As a way of counterbalancing the solemnity of the last performance, this would be as good a time as any to not only lighten the mood, but also talk about one of the all-time greatest misfires/career killers ever experienced on Live TV. For those unfamiliar with who Ashlee Simpson was, some of you may remember her as Jessica’s (somehow/arguably) more talented sister. Of course, because big sister Jess had her star on the rise thanks to an inexplicable TV success with her (now) ex-husband, it was only a matter of time until the rest of the family attempted to ride what was left of her coattails. The ironic part, however, is that in spite of the nepotism, Ashlee at least put in some sort of an effort when it came to becoming a solo artist……………Or at least, that’s what we would’ve thought were it not for her doing an impression of Milli Vanilli one fateful night in Season 30. As the night unfolded, Simpson performed what was her biggest hit from her then new album, “Pieces of Me” with no problem (and for the record, the song is perfectly OK, no fault there), but when it came time for her to perform her 2nd song now lost to the mists of time, that’s where we get to see the above clip in action. Later as the show closed for the night—with host Jude Law comforting her—she first blamed the whole incident on having Acid Reflux; we later found out that she supposedly had voice problems after the first song, so she wanted to use a backing track for her 2nd, but her people cued up the wrong one. We may never TRULY know what happened for sure that night; but one thing’s for sure, it was a Welcome distraction from what was already shaping up to be a lousy season that year (more on That one as well in November). In hindsight, Simpson was able to—eventually—look back on the incident with stride, as evident in this interview with Andy Cohen last year…
In short, I think Simpson has gotten a bum rap for Too Long. And yes, as mentioned in that video, she DID get a do-over the following year that people seemingly forgot about…probably because everybody wrote her off by then—Thankfully not with the same song, nor did they make any further jokes about it; because unlike Milli Vanilli, by the 21st century people knew when to stop beating dead horses. We’re also glad that she’s managed to segue herself into other areas of showbiz now, including a show on the E! network with her current husband Evan Ross…So with that, good for her.
OTHER HONORABLE MENTIONS/SONGS I LIKED (* DENOTES NON-SNL VIDEO):
AC/DC – STIFF UPPER LIP (2000)
RADIOHEAD – THE NATIONAL ANTHEM (2000)
WEEZER – ISLAND IN THE SUN (2001…worth it for Ferrell’s cameo)
*SHAKIRA – WHENEVER, WHEREVER (2001)
*MICK JAGGER – VISIONS OF PARADISE (2001)
P!NK – GET THE PARTY STARTED (2002…feel free to skip “Don’t Let me Get me”)
WHITE STRIPES – WE ARE GONNA BE FRIENDS (2002)
*BECK – NOBODY’S FAULT BUT MY OWN (2003)
SCISSOR SISTERS – TAKE YOUR MAMA (2004)
EMINEM – MOSH/JUST LOSE IT (2004)
*U2 – I WILL FOLLOW (2004) & *ULTRAVIOLET (2009)
*GREEN DAY – BOULEVARD OF BROKEN DREAMS (2005) & *21 GUNS (2009)
*FRANZ FERDINAND – TAKE ME OUT (2005)
*NEIL YOUNG – HE WAS THE KING (2005)
PEARL JAM – WOLRD WIDE SUICIDE (2006)
*RED HOT CHILI PEPPERS – GIVE IT AWAY (2006)
CHRISTINA AGULIERA – HURT (2006)
LILY ALLEN – SMILE (2007…sorry for it being out of sync)
ARCADE FIRE – INTERVENTION (2007)
MARIAH CAREY – TOUCH MY BODY (2008)
*ADELE – CHASING PAVEMENTS (2008)
*COLDPLAY – VIVA LA VIDA (2008)
*TAYLOR SWIFT – YOU BELONG WITH ME (2009)
Did I miss any? Comment Below.
We’ll be back in November with a look at the Silver Linings from a New Breed of Badness, as we take a closer look at seasons 29, 30 & 35. Until then, do me a solid and Catch up on Telehell—it’s gonna be a long wait until the next season, so this would be a good time to catch up on what you missed. Later!